Objective: The authors used a large clinical data set to determine which index diagnoses of schizophrenia spectrum disorder were new diagnoses.
Methods: Using the Massachusetts All-Payer Claims Database (2012–2016), the authors identified patients with a schizophrenia spectrum disorder diagnosis in 2016 (index diagnosis) and then reviewed patients’ care histories for the previous 12, 24, 36, and 48 months to identify previous diagnoses. Logistic regression was used to examine patient characteristics associated with the index diagnosis being a new diagnosis.
Results: Overall, 7,217 individuals ages 15–35 years had a 2016 diagnosis of schizophrenia spectrum disorder; 67.7% had at least 48 months of historical data. Among those with at least 48 months of care history, 23% had no previous diagnoses. Diagnoses from inpatient psychiatric admissions or among female or younger patients were more likely to represent new diagnoses, compared with diagnoses from most other diagnosis locations or among males or older age groups, and outpatient diagnoses were less likely to represent new diagnoses than were most other diagnosis settings. Reviewing 48 instead of 12 months of data reduced estimated rates of new diagnoses from 112 to 66 per 100,000 persons; historical diagnoses were detected for 61% and 77% of patients with 12 or 48 months of care history, respectively.
Conclusions: Examining multiple years of patient history spanning all payers and providers is critical to identifying new schizophrenia spectrum disorder diagnoses in large data sets. Review of 48 months of care history resulted in lower rates of new schizophrenia spectrum disorder diagnoses than previously reported.
Keywords: Diagnosis; Disease classification; Insurance; Public policy issues; Research design; Schizophrenia.